Carl Winger, his face stained with blood, was utterly defeated. Lyona stood with quiet determination.

  Olt stood before Veronica, his voice passionate and sincere, emphasizing community, justice, and ethical principles over cold legalism.

  "Honorable Judge Guzman, we have witnessed today not just a legal dispute, but a stark demonstration of character. We have seen Mr. Winger, under the impartial gaze of Aetheric truth, exposed as guilty. This single, undeniable lie casts a shadow over his entire claim, revealing the self-serving motivations that lie beneath the veneer of 'legitimate business interests'."

  Olt highlighted the contrast between Winger's pursuit of profit and Lyona's unwavering dedication to her community.

  "While Mr. Winger speaks of 'progress' and 'economic development,' Magistrate-Spiritus Lyona speaks of community, of faith, of the human cost of displacement. She is not fighting for personal gain, but for the very soul of her Parish. Her interest is in the well-being of the vulnerable people who rely on its sanctuary and support."

  Olt reiterated how Winger's offers, while technically fulfilling the letter of a commercial relocation, completely violated the spirit of "mutually agreeable terms" in this unique context.

  "The clause 'mutually agreeable terms' is not empty legal jargon. It demands genuine consideration, respectful negotiation, and a good-faith effort to find a solution that works for both parties. Mr. Winger's offers – a paltry stipend, a blighted warehouse on the edge of the district – are not just inadequate, they are a mockery of 'mutual agreement.' They demonstrate a profound disregard for the Parish's inherent value and the human lives intertwined with its existence."

  Olt then appealed to Synoran values and "The Synoran Way."

  "Honorable Judge, we are Synorans. We understand that contracts are not merely cold, legalistic documents, but reflections of our shared values, our commitment to community, our understanding of justice. The 'Synoran Way' is not about ruthless profit at any cost; it is about balance, about compassion, about protecting the vulnerable. Enforcing this contract on Mr. Winger's terms would be a betrayal of those very values, a stain on the fabric of our community."

  Eh, I’m not sure I believe half of what I just said. And this is why I didn’t wanna be an advocate.

  Olt concluded with a powerful, emotionally resonant call for justice.

  "Therefore, Honorable Judge Guzman, I implore you to rule not just on the letter of a flawed contract, but on the spirit of Synoran justice. Rule in favor of Magistrate-Spiritus Lyona, rule in favor of her community, rule in favor of compassion and fairness. Let your judgment today be a testament to the values we hold dear."

  Olt bowed and stepped away. He smiled at Lyona as he walked past her. Lyona stood with quiet dignity.

  The Prosecutor, Fiona, began her closing statement, their tone defensive and legalistic, aiming for damage control.

  "Honorable Judge Guzman, while my client, Mr. Winger, may have… erred… in his response to a single, tangential question, I urge the court to not allow this minor… imprecision… to distract from the fundamental legal facts of this case."

  Fiona reiterated the legal validity of the contract.

  "Magistrate-Spiritus Lyona did sign a legally binding contract. This fact is undeniable. Synoran law, and indeed, any functional legal system, rests upon the principle that contracts must be honored. To rule against Mr. Winger would be to undermine the very foundation of contractual law in Synoro, setting a dangerous precedent."

  Fiona reframed Winger's offers as "commercially reasonable."

  "Mr. Winger's offers, while perhaps not meeting Magistrate-Spiritus Lyona's ideal… and frankly, unrealistic… demands, are demonstrably commercially reasonable. He offered a financial stipend, rent-free space, and a potential for future expansion. These are tangible, concrete offers, exceeding what is legally required in many similar commercial relocation cases."

  She attacked Lyona's "unreasonableness" and "emotionalism."

  "Magistrate-Spiritus Lyona's defense rests on purely emotional appeals and subjective interpretations of 'mutually agreeable terms.' She has presented no concrete, legally sound justification for breaking this contract, only a series of escalating and ultimately unreasonable demands. Her resistance is not about justice, but about a refusal to adapt to the realities of a changing Synoran economy."

  Fiona concluded with a plea for legal order and "progress," minimizing moral and ethical concerns.

  "Honorable Judge Guzman, while we sympathize with Magistrate-Spiritus Lyona's situation, sentimentality cannot override the law. Upholding contracts, even difficult ones, is essential for a stable and prosperous Synoro. I urge you to rule in favor of my client, Mr. Carl Winger, and uphold the sanctity of contract law, ensuring that 'progress,' however challenging, can continue to move forward in Sector 1."

  This story has been taken without authorization. Report any sightings.

  Veronica listened intently to both closing statements, maintaining a neutral expression throughout.

  After the Prosecutor concluded, Veronica paused. It was a slow smile that spread across her face. She turned to Ganjo, a subtle amusement in her eyes.

  "Well, Ganjo," she said, smiling, with a slight shrug, "it seems you do have a knack for spotting talent. A good choice, indeed."

  Rebecca exchanged a quick, subtle smile with Olt. Her smile featured a nod of approval with a slight widening of her eyes, conveying impressed surprise. Mariah leaned forward slightly, a genuine, warm smile spreading across her face. She softly clapped her hands, showing open appreciation for Olt's victory.

  Veronica turned to address the room, her smile now edged with sarcasm. She raised an eyebrow, addressing everyone present. She held a pointed look at Carl.

  "Now, before we proceed to the… sentencing phase… let's be clear. For anyone still under the illusion, I am not a Magistrate. This is not an official Synoran court. And Mr. Winger," she gestured towards Carl with a dismissive wave, "…as he is acutely aware, was… persuaded… to be here today."

  Veronica's tone became decisive, all traces of sarcasm vanishing.

  "That being said, a judgment has been rendered. Based on the arguments presented, and the… demonstrable lack of good faith… from the Plaintiff, I find in favor of the Defense. Magistrate-Spiritus Lyona, you are not obligated to relocate your Parish based on this contract, under the current terms offered."

  Carl Winger's confident facade crumbled. He exploded in anger, now free from Rebecca's Aether paralysis.

  "This is outrageous! Kidnapping! Illegal proceedings! You can't do this! This isn't justice, it's a mockery!"

  He pointed a trembling finger at Veronica and the group.

  "I will sue! I will file an official complaint! You think you can get away with this? You'll be hearing from my real lawyers! This is highly illegal!"

  Veronica remained seated, completely unfazed by Winger's outburst. Her smile returned, but now it was chillingly predatory.

  "Mr. Winger, please. Do not bore me with empty threats. You will do no such thing."

  She leaned forward slightly, locking onto Winger's eyes. Her tone became even more menacing.

  "You will abide by my decision. Or shall I remind you of the… fragile… foundations of your own… business empire?"

  She listed leverage points with chilling precision.

  "Let's recap, shall we? A fleet of trucks acquired for pennies on the dollar, thanks to connections I believe we both know… trucks that are, shall we say, less than legally obtained?"

  Carl visibly paled. A cold sweat broke out on his forehead as realization dawned.

  Veronica continued, pressing her advantage.

  "And then there's your company, 'Winger Distribution'… a rather impressive operation, for someone with no registered ownership whatsoever, isn't it? A shell, perhaps? For… the 'Synoran Prosperity Initiative,' perhaps?" She said the last phrase with pointed emphasis, watching Carl's reaction.

  Carl was now visibly terrified, eyes wide with panic.

  Veronica delivered the final, crushing blow.

  "There are many names attached to that 'Initiative,' Mr. Winger. But yours… isn't one of them. You are, as they say, just a front. And if you breathe a word of this unofficial proceeding to the official authorities, you will find yourself facing real Magistrates…in a Uraan court. Do you understand, Mr. Winger?"

  Carl Winger was utterly defeated, his bravado completely gone. He shrunk back, visibly terrified.

  "…Yes… Yes, I understand… I… I won't say anything…" he stammered.

  He was thoroughly intimidated and agreed to Veronica's terms, knowing he was completely outmatched.

  Lyona approached Veronica and Olt, a wave of relief washing over her weary face.

  "Veronica, thank you," Lyona said, with genuine gratitude. "Thank you for your… justice. I just hope it doesn’t cause more trouble."

  Mariah then turned to Olt, her eyes widening in recognition. "And you… you are… Olt, yes? From the Parish? You came to visit me… at the chapel…"

  “I am,” Olt confirmed with a smile. “I wondered if you remembered. Guess you did.”

  "Thank you, Olt," she said, with heartfelt thanks. "For your words. For your help. You spoke for us… for our community… when we could not."

  Veronica dismissed Lyona's thanks with a wave of her hand, her focus already shifting to the next phase.

  "Enough with the pleasantries, Magistrate-Spiritus. We are not finished here. We now move to the sentencing phase."

  Veronica’s tone became businesslike, cutting through the emotion.

  "Normally, as you know, the advocate who litigates is not the same to participate in Trial by Combat. But… today, we are making an exception. I am… curious… to see if our Advocate for the Defense is as skilled in other arenas as he is with words."

  Veronica turned to Olt, a challenging glint in her eyes.

  "Magistrate-Spiritus Lyona has won the litigation phase, thanks to your advocacy, Mr. Bartholomew. But now, can you fight for her victory as well?"

  Olt was visibly startled by Veronica's demand, his eyes widening in surprise. He looked quickly at Ganjo for guidance.

  "Trial by Combat? But… I'm not…"

  Ganjo shrugged, a subtle, almost imperceptible movement. He began to grow anxious.

  Veronica clapped her hands together. It was a decisive sound that signaled the end of the litigation phase and the start of the sentencing negotiations.

  "Fiona and Mr. Bartholomew… to the platform. Present your sentencing negotiations. Let us see if you can be as creative with sentencing as you were with your arguments."